By Dennis Sadowski
CLEVELAND (CNS) — The president of Catholic Charities USA said the agency would turn to Capitol Hill to get a pandemic relief bill passed after it called President Donald Trump’s decision to suspend talks on the legislation “heartless.”
Dominican Sister Donna Markham told Catholic News Service early Oct. 7 that the president’s decision the day before to pull out of talks and to wait until after the Nov. 3 election to negotiate a bill would stress families that are struggling with unemployment because of the economic recession caused by the coronavirus pandemic.
“I’m extremely concerned about the food shortage and the inability of people to purchase food for their families or to pay their rents. To deprive them of their well-being and the well-being of their children in this time seems to me to be extremely cruel,” Sister Markham said.
Her comments followed the agency’s strong reaction soon after Trump said he was suspending talks with congressional Democrats on a measure.
“This heartless decision is incomprehensible,” Catholic Charities USA said Oct. 6.
Archbishop Paul S. Coakley of Oklahoma City, chairman of the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops’ Committee on Domestic Justice and Human Development, also urged reconsideration of the move.
“I ask the president to reverse his decision, and for all parties to return to negotiations as soon as possible,” he said Oct. 7.
“Tens of millions of Americans urgently need help today. They need help in getting enough food, paying the rent or mortgage, finding work, affording health care, and accessing good schools. We have been imploring lawmakers since April to address these needs,” he said, citing eight different appeals the bishops have made.
He referred to Pope Francis’ new encyclical, “Fratelli Tutti,” in which the pontiff said: “Now there are only two kinds of people: those who care for someone who is hurting and those who pass by; those who bend down to help and those who look the other way and hurry off. Here, all our distinctions, labels and masks fall away: it is the moment of truth. Will we bend down to touch and heal the wounds of others? Will we bend down and help another to get up? This is today’s challenge, and we should not be afraid to face it. In moments of crisis, decisions become urgent.”
The president and CEO of the Catholic Health Association of the United States, Mercy Sister Mary Haddad, added her concerns over the delay Oct. 8, saying in a statement that any delay in negotiations was “unacceptable.”
She said her organization was “deeply disturbed by the administration’s refusal to work with Congress to pass a critically important” piece of legislation.
“The effects of the pandemic will not wait until after the election, they need to be addressed now,” Sister Haddad.
Hours after announcing the suspension of negotiations, Trump seemingly reversed course in a series of tweets in which he urged members of his administration to work with congressional Democrats on a limited package of federal stimulus measures.
Talks between House Speaker Nancy Pelosi and Treasury Secretary Steven Mnuchin have been stalled over the size and extent of a new round of stimulus spending. House Democrats have passed two measures, the first at $3 trillion and the second a slimmer bill of about $2 trillion. The White House has said it wants to cap spending at $1.6 trillion.
Key disagreements have focused on the size of weekly jobless benefits and the amount of aid for state and local governments that are facing large budget shortfalls because of reduced tax revenues and increased spending during the economic downturn.
Democrats also have opposed a piecemeal approach to stimulus measures, saying they prefer a comprehensive package be adopted.
Trump’s series of tweets called for $25 billion in new aid for the airline industry, which is already seeing massive layoffs, another $1,200 in direct payments to millions of Americans and $135 billion in aid for small businesses.
“I am ready to sign right now,” he wrote. “Are you listening, Nancy?”
The apparent reversal did not satisfy Sister Markham, who maintained that families need aid as quickly as possible.
“We’re going to continue to speak with our contacts on the Hill and advocate for reconsideration of this today (Oct. 7),” she said.
In its Oct. 6 statement, Catholic Charities USA said the relief package was needed as soon as possible because the country “is experiencing a profound crisis with over 210,000 lives lost, 30 million Americans relying on unemployment assistance, and communities continuing to fight COVID-19 surges.”
It said charitable agencies are stretched beyond their means in an effort to respond to the demand for assistance.
“The Gospel compels us to care for those who are in need of help, but charitable organizations are not able to shoulder the enormity of these needs,” the statement said. “The administration and Congress must renew their negotiations and pass legislation as soon as possible.”
