Book Reviews

Benedictine Sister’s Tale of a Medieval Church Women’s Group

By Kathleen Finley

“The Wisdom of the Beguines: The Forgotten Story of a Medieval Women’s Movement” by Laura Swan. Blue Bridge (Katonah, New York, 2014), 202 pp., $16.95.

beguines1The Beguines are a fascinating group of women, and the more one learns about them, the more intriguing they become. Benedictine Sister Laura Swan has written a book that is clear and not technical, accessible and balanced to those unfamiliar with these unique figures, while full of information for those who may already know about them. She presents the story of a group of women who not only defied the categories of the church and the state of the time, but who also continue to blur them now in the telling of it.

Sister Swan explains about the movement that began in the 1200s:

“The Beguines were a phenomenal way of life that swept across Europe, yet they were never a religious order or a formalized movement. And they did not have one specific founder or rule to live by. But there were common elements that rendered these women distinctive and familiar, including their common way of life, chastity and simplicity, their unusual business acumen, and their commitment to God and to the poor and marginalized. … They lived by themselves or together in so-called beguinages, which could be single houses for as few as a handful of Beguines or, as in Bruges, Belgium, walled-in rows of houses enclosing a central court with a chapel where over a thousand Beguines might live … And each region of Europe has its own Beguine stories to tell.”

These women were dangerous to the institution of the Church in various ways; they taught that ordinary people could experience a deep connection to God without the need of an intermediary such as the clergy or hierarchy, and many were themselves mystics, those who experience God’s love directly.

“These women spoke from the depth of their experience of God, rather than from mere rational, philosophical argument. Knowledge of God was first and foremost gained in experiencing God’s love and in loving God in return.” They battled charges of heresy at times, and Sister Swan admits that a few may have indeed been heretics.

Sister Swan shows us how they lived, and what they did in ministry, in their writing and preaching. She provides a clear, reliable source for a long-neglected topic, and her survey is grounded in solid scholarship.

Although some may find that her circle of inclusion is a bit too wide when she includes figures such as St. Catherine of Siena as a Beguine, she reminds us that a group of medieval women, across various centuries and ethnic groups, embodied Gospel freedom in a way that still intrigues us.

Finley is the author of several books on practical spirituality, and has taught religious studies at Gonzaga University, Spokane, Wash., for many years.