International News

Court Rules Archbishop Viganò Must Repay $2 Million to His Brother

By Crux Staff

Archbishop Carlo Maria Vigano, former apostolic nuncio to the U.S., is seen in a 2016 photo in Washington. (Photo: Catholic News Service/Gregory A. Shemitz)

ROME (Crux) – Last month Archbishop Carlo Maria Viganò, a former papal ambassador who in recent months gained global fame for publishing a statement asking Pope Francis to resign, lost a civil lawsuit against his brother over a family estate.

In an October ruling, the Civil Court of Milan sentenced Archbishop Viganò to compensate his brother, Father Lorenzo Viganò, over $2 million, including interest and court costs, in a feud over their family assets.

The archbishop, who for years worked as an official of the Governorate of Vatican City, eventually becoming secretary general, served as papal ambassador to the U.S. from 2011 to 2016. He first exploded into the public spotlight when he became the central figure in what has become known as the “Vatikleaks” scandal of 2011-2012.

At the time, confidential letters were stolen from then-Pope Benedict XVI’s desk by his butler, Paolo Gabriele, and leaked to Italian journalist Gianluigi Nuzzi. Among the most noteworthy documents leaked were two letters from Viganò addressed to Benedict and the Vatican Secretary of State at the time, Cardinal Tarcisio Bertone, alleging various forms of financial and personal corruption and insisting that his appointment to the U.S. was made in a bid to get rid of him for trying to crack down on illicit financial activities.

At the time of his transfer, Archbishop Viganò initially claimed that he was unable to take up the U.S. post on grounds that he needed to stay behind and care for an ailing Father Lorenzo. However, Father Lorenzo responded to his brother’s claim, saying his brother was taking advantage of his illness in order to gain control of family property and wanted to remain in Rome to ensure he didn’t lose his grip.

Based in Chicago, Father Lorenzo had suffered a debilitating stroke that left him in a wheelchair, yet he insisted that he and his brother had not been on good terms for years, nullifying Archbishop Viganò’s argument of taking care of him.

The two brothers had jointly held their family’s assets, including real estate which in 2010, a year before the archbishop’s transfer to the U.S., was estimated at a value of over $22 million, in addition to a cash sum amounting to nearly $8 million.

Archbishop Viganò himself had managed the inheritance and according to the sentence from the Milan civil court, since his move had continued to receive the real estate revenues and cash, obtaining over $4 million, according to Italian news site La Stampa.

In their sentence, the court ordered that Archbishop Viganò must now pay half of the sum to his brother Father Lorenzo, who was sued by Archbishop Viganò shortly before the Vatileaks scandal. Father Lorenzo had previously sued his brother in 2010.

On Aug. 26, Viganò entered into the public spotlight again when he published an 11-page statement accusing several high-level members of the Roman Curia, including Pope Francis, of mishandling allegations of sexual misconduct on the part of former Cardinal Theodore McCarrick. He called out several prelates whom he alleged were part of a gay lobby inside the Vatican, and asked the pope to resign over his failure to properly address concerns that had been raised about McCarrick.

He has since published two other statements, and most recently, signed a message ahead of the fall general assembly of the United States Conference of Catholic Bishops, asking them to resist Pope Francis.

Share this article with a friend.