VIDEO: Alumna Seeks Landmark Status for Visitation Monastery, Academy in Brooklyn

Caroline Cardillo says history lives beyond the locked gates of Visitation Monastery and Academy, where 120 years of faith have been shaped — including her own.

“Visitation was a huge part of my formation as a person, as a Catholic, as a student. You know, it was everything,” Cardillo said.That is why she says it cannot disappear.

In a 430-page request for evaluation to the New York City Landmarks Preservation Commission, Cardillo is pushing to have the 7.5-acre property declared historic in an effort for it to remain a sanctuary of stillness in the heart of Bay Ridge.

“We just always believed that it would be there for all time. It’s a love story to the school that we loved, to the sisters that we loved. And it’s our way to say thank you for everything that they gave us,” she told The Tablet.

RELATED: Hundreds Rally Demanding Landmark Status for Visitation Academy Property in Brooklyn

In 2024, due to dwindling numbers, the Sisters of the Visitation closed the monastery and ended their sponsorship of the K-through-8 academy where Cardillo graduated in 2000.

Before it was the monastery, the building was the Kings County Inebriates Home. Cardillo said that in one way or another, it has always been a beacon of hope.

“This was a time in this country where people that suffered with addiction were put in asylums. They were incarcerated. And the Kings County Inebriate Home really offered hope and second chances for the people that were there,” she explained.

RELATED: How Visitation Academy Helped Lead Sister Ita Ford To a Life of Faith, Service

As of this past summer, the property was under contract to be sold for $42 million. What buyers intended for it is not clear, but Cardillo’s call to action is: Bay Ridge, Brooklyn and New York City need to preserve this piece of the past.

“It’s incredibly historically significant and really nothing else like it in New York City,” she said.