Diocesan News

Hundreds Rally Demanding Landmark Status for Visitation Academy Property in Brooklyn

Following the rally, many of the participants marched around the two-block perimeter of the Visitation Academy property. (Photo: Ed Wilkinson)

BAY RIDGE — Carrying homemade signs and marching along the 20-foot stone walls that surround the shuttered Visitation Academy, supporters of the Bay Ridge school called on New York City on Nov. 14 to declare its 7.5-acre property a landmark — before a new owner, whose plans remain unknown, decides its fate.

“There’s a great depth of history to this property that really needs to be preserved,” Caroline Cardillo, who graduated from Visitation Academy in 2000 and formed the Visitation Academy and Monastery Landmark Initiative, told The Tablet before the rally. Cardillo estimated the crowd, which included preservationists, former teachers and several generations of Visitation alums, at 500 to 600.

This past summer, the property owners, the Sisters of the Visitation, obtained approval from New York State Attorney General Letitia James to sell the property to an entity known as 1137 91 LLC for $42.2 million. Under state law, the Sisters of the Visitation, as a non-profit, had to secure approval from the attorney general.

The group behind 1137 91 LLC has not publicly stated what they intend to do with the property. The property, which takes up two city blocks and is hidden behind 20-foot-high stone walls, contains Visitation Academy, a K-8 school for girls that closed in 2024, a monastery, chapel, and a convent, along with a small lake and clusters of trees.

VIDEO: Visitation Academy and Monastery Landmark Initiative Makes Push to Save Historic Bay Ridge Property

The property has stood empty since the academy closed in 2024 and its sponsor, the Sisters of the Visitation, left shortly after.

On Oct. 1, Cardillo filed a 430-page request for evaluation with the New York City Landmarks Preservation Commission seeking landmark status for the entire property at 8902 Ridge Blvd. The application details the history of the property — all the way back to the 19th century before the arrival of the Sisters of the Visitation and the establishment of the school — to bolster the argument for preservation.

City Councilmember Kayla Santosuosso, who represents Bay Ridge, told the crowd at the rally that she brought the issue directly to the Landmarks Preservation Commission.

“I met with the LPC chair and demanded that this be calendared,” she said, referring to the process by which a landmarking request is formally placed under consideration by LPC and hearings are set. “They do not hear us. They have not heard us. And I am so happy that we are all gathered here today because they are going to hear us now.” 

Archival photo shows the grounds of Visitation Monastery in 1913. (Photo: Courtesy of Caroline Cardillo)

A spokesperson for the Landmarks Preservation Commission told The Tablet that the LPC staff has determined that the primary chapel building facing Ridge Boulevard appears to merit consideration as an individual landmark, but that further study would be needed to understand the significance and integrity of the overall site. 

In 2024, the Sisters of the Visitation announced that, with only two sisters left, they would close the monastery, move out, and end their sponsorship of Visitation Academy — the school they established in 1903 after relocating from Clinton Street in Downtown Brooklyn to Bay Ridge. 

Cardillo said she is aware there’s the possibility that new owners will use the property to develop housing, but that shouldn’t stop the Landmark Initiative from pressing forward.

“We understand that there’s a housing crisis in New York and that homes are needed. But that doesn’t have to come at the cost of preservation and tearing down one-of-a-kind 19th-century buildings,” she said, highlighting that the property housed the Kings County Inebriates in 19th-century history — before the Sisters of Visitation moved there — as a facility for the treatment of alcoholism and other forms of substance abuse.  

RELATED: Visitation Monastery Property in Bay Ridge, Brooklyn Nears Sale

“It was groundbreaking in its way,” Cardillo explained. “The Kings County Inebriate Home was different because they believed that treatment was possible. And the grounds and the lake were all part of the treatment.” 

Two of the treatment center buildings — one built in 1869 and the other in 1888 — are still standing. The Sisters of the Visitation later adapted both for their own use. 

Charles Fiore, former president of the Visitation Academy Father’s Club and a member of the Landmark Initiative’s executive board, said the rally offered participants a chance to pay tribute to the school’s legacy.

“Today is a celebration of all the great times we had here and the great times ahead,” Fiore said.