After another competitive season of CHSAA varsity softball action, here’s a look at The Tablet’s 2026 diocesan All-Star team. A special thanks goes out to the league’s coaches for providing nominations.
TIER 1
ARCHBISHOP MOLLOY
Kimmy Piazza: senior; pitcher/outfielder; team co-captain; 15-2 record, 123 innings pitched, 1.48 ERA, 126 strikeouts; named CHSAA Tier 1 All-League; won team co-MVP Award; will attend St. John’s University, Jamaica; 2024 and 2025 Tablet All-Star
Diem Nenadich: junior; shortstop; team co-captain; .412 avg., 5 home runs, 4 triples, 10 doubles, 30 stolen bases; named CHSAA Tier 1 All-League; won team co-MVP Award; 2024 and 2025 Tablet All-Star
Nicole Berinato: senior; outfielder; .393 avg., 23 RBI; named CHSAA Tier 1 All League
Victoria Barrientos: junior; second base; .386 avg., 5 triples, 15 RBI; 2025 Tablet All-Star
Amber Mangold: junior; outfielder/pitcher; .365 avg., 3 home runs, 3 triples, 27 RBI
Adrianna LaGrega: freshman; third base; .322 avg., 15 RBI
XAVERIAN
Avery Matone: sophomore; pitcher; 14 wins, 93 innings pitched, 1.88 ERA, 143 strikeouts; named CHSAA Tier 1 All League; won team MVP Award
Sienna Bocchino: senior; outfielder; .562 avg., 19 stolen bases; named CHSAA Tier 1 All-League; won team Offensive Player of the Year Award; will attend the University of Mississippi; 2023, 2024, and 2025 Tablet All-Star
Madison Pender: senior; third base; .492 avg., 4 home runs, 27 RBI; won team Most Outstanding Player Award; will attend the University of Hartford; 2025 Tablet All-Star
Sofia Mauro: junior; catcher; .360 avg., 28 RBI; won team Defensive Player of the Year Award
THE MARY LOUIS ACADEMY
Rachele Iovine: senior; utility; team captain; named CHSAA Tier 1 All League; won team MVP Award; will attend Lake Region State College in North Dakota while also playing professional softball in Italy for Inox Team Saronno of the Italian Serie A1 softball league
ST. FRANCIS PREP
Mia Modica: junior; infielder/outfielder/pitcher; team captain; .480 avg., 28 hits, 8 doubles, 18 RBI, 22 runs scored; won team co-MVP and Highest Avg. Awards; 2024 and 2025 Tablet All-Star
DeAnna DeLutri: junior; catcher/third base; team captain; .385 avg., 20 hits, 4 doubles, 3 triples, 17 RBI, 16 runs scored; won team co-MVP Award; named CHSAA Tier 1 All League; 2025 and 2025 Tablet All-Star
FONTBONNE HALL ACADEMY
Katelyn Kmiotek: senior; pitcher; .520 avg., 2.84 ERA, 36 strikeouts; named CHSAA Tier 1 All-League; will attend Stony Brook University; 2024 and 2025 Tablet All-Star
Grace McGinn: junior; first base; .581 slugging percentage, .968 fielding percentage
Angelina Soranno: freshman; pitcher; 1.60 ERA, 25 strikeouts
Reese Pearlman: freshman; utility; 1.000 fielding percentage
Samantha Spyliopulos: junior; shortstop; 1.000 fielding percentage; 2025 Tablet All-Star
MSGR. MCCLANCY
Rosalie DeStefano: junior; pitcher/infielder; .263 avg., 5 RBI, 70.1 innings pitched, 84 strikeouts; named CHSAA Tier 1 All-League; 2025 Tablet All-Star
Kaiya Sciacco: senior; outfielder; team captain; .316 avg., 7 RBI, 1.000 fielding percentage; won team MVP Award; will attend Bridgeport University; 2024 and 2025 Tablet All-Star
Alison Toribio: senior; shortstop/utility; .385 avg., 2 home runs, 7 RBI; won team Offensive Player Award; will attend Bridgeport University; 2025 Tablet All-Star
TIER 2
ST. EDMUND PREP
Matilda Puckhaber: junior; pitcher; 92 strikeouts; named CHSAA Tier 2 All League; won team MVP Award; 2024 and 2025 Tablet All-Star
Rosalie Sterling: freshman; third base; .514 avg.; named CHSAA Tier 2 All-League; won team Coach’s Award
Jenna Lankford: junior; shortstop; .421 avg.; won team Coach’s Award; 2025 Tablet All-Star
TIER 3
BISHOP LOUGHLIN
Isabella Duverge: senior; shortstop; team captain; .657 avg., 6 doubles, 4 triples, 5 home runs, 31 runs scored, 33 RBI; named CHSAA Tier 3 All-League; won team Co-MVP and Bonilla Awards; will attend St. Petersburg College; 2024 and 2025 Tablet All-Star
Isidora Fuentes: senior; pitcher; team captain; .360 avg., 5 doubles, 25 runs scored, 17 RBI, 13-0 record, 83 strikeouts; named CHSAA Tier 3 All-League; won team Co-MVP and Bonilla Awards; 2023, 2024, and 2025 Tablet All-Star
Leah Gethers: senior; first base; .468 avg., 14 runs scored, 11 RBI; won team Best Defensive Player Award; 2025 Tablet All-Star
Hannah Morales: junior; catcher; .563 avg., 5 doubles, 24 runs scored, 23 RBI; named CHSAA Tier 3 All League; won team Game Changer Award; 2024 and 2025 Tablet All-Star
HOLY CROSS
Riley Brana: freshman; pitcher; .486 avg., 19 RBI, 21 runs scored. 9-7 record, 171 strikeouts (school record); named CHSAA Tier 3 All-League; won team MVP Award
Jessica Connolly: sophomore; catcher; team captain; .500 avg., 3 home runs, 31 runs scored; won team Offensive and Defensive Player of the Year Awards; 2025 Tablet All-Star
ST. SAVIOUR
Alexis Danticat: junior; pitcher/shortstop; team captain; .458 avg., 3 home runs, 13 RBI, 43 innings pitched, 88 strikeouts; named CHSAA Tier 3 All-League; 2025 Tablet All-Star
ST. JOHN’S PREP
Valeria Sinche: senior; second base; .305 avg., 2 home runs; named CHSAA Tier 3 All-League; 2025 Tablet All Star
CHRIST THE KING
Saniyah Luna-Jimenez: senior; shortstop; team captain; .548 avg., 23 hits, 7 home runs, 29 RBI, 27 runs scored; named CHSAA Tier 3 All-League; 2025 Tablet All-Star
Mailia Fuentes: senior; second base/outfielder; .436 avg., 17 hits, 4 home runs, 22 RBI, 16 runs scored; named CHSAA Tier 3 All-League
CRISTO REY BROOKLYN
Summer Green: senior; utility; named CHSAA Tier 3 All League