Sports

Bay Ridge’s Comeback Kids: Fontbonne Reaches City Final

Fontbonne Hall Academy players take the field during their 2026 varsity soccer season. After going winless the previous two years, the Bonnies completed a dramatic turnaround and reached the CHSAA Tier 2 city championship final. (Photo: Courtesy of Fontbonne Hall Academy)

While our local diocesan CHSAA prides itself on being much more than wins and losses, winning at least a handful of games throughout a season makes high school sports enjoyable — since student-athletes see the fruits of their labor.

For the Fontbonne Hall Academy, Bay Ridge, varsity soccer team, wins have been hard to come by the past two seasons. Not only have they been hard to come by, but in fact, they’ve been nonexistent, as the Bonnies dropped 25 consecutive matches from 2024 through 2025.

This fall season, that all changed, as a new coaching regime guided the squad to a complete turnaround. We’re not just talking a handful of wins here. The Bonnies stunned the CHSAA soccer world by finishing the campaign as the Tier 2 city championship finalists.

RELATED: Former Hoops Pro, Brooklyn Native Returns to Roots as Fontbonne’s New Athletic Director

Following a winless 2025 season, Fontbonne opened the search for a new varsity head coach. Athletic administrators selected Peter Touros, a former collegiate and semi-pro soccer player, to take the reins of the program.

Touros is also club director of Kosmos FC TST, a premier youth soccer club serving Queens and South Brooklyn. His playing and coaching career has taken him around the globe, so the Bonnies had an experienced, dedicated leader heading into this season.

Touros added Jasmine Hewitt, one of his former players who went on to have a successful career at the University of Mount Saint Vincent, the Bronx, as his assistant coach. Hewitt’s passion for the game and ability to connect with the student-athletes made her more like a co-head coach.

Right from the start of workouts, the team experienced a full-fledged culture change. The students — the same group that hadn’t won a single match in two years — sensed things were different and became motivated to forge a new path forward.

“I definitely think that I was a little more passionate coming into this year,” said Joanne Maropakis, a senior midfielder and team co-captain from Bay Ridge who played all four years on varsity and who was named to the CHSAA Tier 2 All-League Team. “The level of intensity with a more soccer-affiliated coach inspired me to properly prepare before the season. Soccer was finally taken seriously and got the recognition it deserves.”

In the team’s first match of the season, the Bonnies turned in an impressive 4-1 victory over St. John’s Prep, Astoria, which had competed in the Tier 1 league the year prior.

Senior forward and team co-captain Olivia Teich — also a four-year varsity player from St. Francis de Sales, Belle Harbor, and a CHSAA Tier 2 All-League selection — scored the first goal of the season, and it felt like a huge weight had been lifted.

“It was definitely something special, especially at the start of my senior year, because we had no wins for two years,” Teich said. “I had been losing hope until Coach Peter and Coach Jasmine came in. Right away, the hope of winning and loving soccer again came back, especially after that first win.”

Wins began piling up for the Bonnies. With 12 wins in the regular season, Fontbonne entered the city championship playoffs as the No. 3 seed out of six teams. In the quarterfinals, the Bonnies defeated St. John’s Prep, 5-2.

The semifinal match pitted Fontbonne against Moore Catholic H.S., Staten Island — fresh off defeating the Bonnies on the latter’s senior night. When the dust settled, Fontbonne emerged with a 3-1 win to set up a finals match against a talented Kennedy Catholic H.S. team from Somers, New York, which had consistently averaged upwards of 6-8 goals per game all season.

In the regular season, Kennedy Catholic beat Fontbonne 6-0 in their first meeting, but the Bonnies rebounded in the second match for a tight 1-0 win. The final match was intense from start to finish, with a fluke goal by Kennedy early in the second half ultimately sealing their 1-0 title win.

Still, Fontbonne reaching the final match after two fully winless seasons shows just how far this program has come in such a short time. The team exceeded all expectations, especially in its first season with a new head coach.

“I’m immensely proud of these girls because some of them took a risk to be on the soccer team,” Touros said. “Who comes out and takes a risk to be on a losing team for fun? We have girls in the program who could have easily quit to not go through another year of this.

“But they all came back; they all believed in the system, and they all believed in us. This was probably one of the most fun coaching experiences I’ve had in 20 years of coaching.”

Now that a new foundation has been established, it will be interesting to see where the Bonnies go from here. Fontbonne truly had the Brooklyn soccer scene buzzing these last few weeks, so let’s hope this CHSAA title contender is here to stay.