After another exciting season of CHSAA girls’ varsity basketball, here’s a look at The Tablet’s annual diocesan All-Star team (with their season per-game averages). Special thanks to the league’s coaches for providing nominations.
RELATED: The Tablet’s High School Boys’ ’25-’26 Basketball All-Stars
‘AAA’
Josephine Pinnock: Christ the King H.S., Middle Village; junior; guard; team co-captain; averaged 16.5 points and 6.2 assists; named CHSAA ‘AAA’ MVP; 2024 and 2025 Tablet All-Star
Olivia Vukosa: Christ the King; senior; center; team co-captain; averaged 17.9 points and 18.0 rebounds; selected CHSAA ‘AAA’ All- League First Team; named a McDonald’s High School All-American; selected 2025- 2026 New York State Gatorade Player of the Year; will play at UCONN; 2023, 2024, and 2025 Tablet All-Star
Arielle Lopez: Christ the King; junior; guard; team co-captain; averaged 12.0 points; selected CHSAA ‘AAA’ All-League Third Team; 2024 and 2025 Tablet All-Star
Arly Zapata: Nazareth H.S., East Flatbush; senior; center; averaged 15.0 points and 11.0 rebounds; selected CHSAA ‘AAA’ All-League First Team; will play at Coppin State University; 2025 Tablet All-Star
Callie Mullin: Xaverian H.S., Bay Ridge; senior; guard; team captain; averaged 15.0points, 5.0 rebounds, and 5.0 assists; scored her 1,000th career point this season; selected CHSAA ‘AAA’ All- League Second Team; will play at Mercy University; 2024 and 2025 Tablet All-Star
Isabella Grimaldi: Xaverian; junior; guard; averaged 18.0 points, 6.0 rebounds, and 4.0 assists; selected CHSAA ‘AAA’ All-League Third Team; 2025 Tablet All-Star
Kristen Vargas: St. Francis Prep, Fresh Meadows; senior; guard; team captain; averaged 16.5 points; selected CHSAA ‘AAA’ All-League Third Team; named recipient of CHSAA Marianne Noonan Sportsmanship Award; will play at Farmingdale State College; 2025 Tablet All-Star
‘AA’
Layla Wagner: Msgr. McClancy H.S., East Elmhurst; junior; guard; team co-captain; averaged 21.0 points, 7.0 rebounds, 5.0 assists, and 4.0 steals; scored her 1,000th career point this season; became all-time leading scorer in school’s girls’ program history; named CHSAA ‘AA’ Division MVP; 2024 and 2025 Tablet All-Star
Maleah Wagner: Msgr. McClancy; junior; guard; team co-captain; averaged 13.5 points, 5.0 rebounds, 4.0 steals, and 3.0 assists; selected CHSAA ‘AA’ All-League First Team; 2025 Tablet All-Star
Vanessa Hosey: Msgr. McClancy; junior; guard; averaged 10.0 points per game
Ava Thomas: The Mary Louis Academy, Jamaica Estates; senior; guard; team captain; averaged 15.0 points, 5.0 rebounds, 5.0 assists, and 2.0 steals; selected CHSAA ‘AA’ All-League First Team; scored her 1,000th career point this season; named recipient of CHSAA Sandi Capifali Sportsmanship Award; will play at Quinnipiac University
Sofia Hamilton: Holy Cross H.S., Flushing; junior; guard; team captain; averaged 18.0 points; selected CHSAA ‘AA’ All- League First Team
Madison Glasco: Holy Cross; junior; guard; averaged 18.0 points; selected CHSAA ‘AA’ All-League Second Team
Olivia Schnurer: Holy Cross; senior; guard; averaged 12.0 points per game, made 86 3-pointers (led N.Y. state)
Molly Trears: Archbishop Molloy H.S.; junior; forward; team co-captain; averaged 19.0 points, 7.0 rebounds, and 3.0 steals; selected CHSAA ‘AA’ All-League First Team; 2024 and 2025 Tablet All-Star
Brooke D’Asaro: Archbishop Molloy; junior; guard; team co-captain; averaged 11.0 points; 2025 Tablet All Star
Aubrey Neos: Archbishop Molloy; senior; guard; team co-captain; averaged 7.0 points and 3.0 assists; 2025 Tablet All Star
Marlene Marks: Bishop Loughlin H.S., Fort Greene; freshman; guard; team co-captain; averaged 15.0 points; selected CHSAA ‘AA’ All- League Third Team
Malia Petit: Bishop Loughlin; junior; guard; team co-captain; lead team in assists
Victoria Savin: St. John’s Prep, Astoria; junior; center; averaged 10.0 points, 11.0 rebounds, and 3.0 blocks; selected CHSAA ‘AA’ All-League Second Team; 2024 and 2025 Tablet All-Star
Livia Savino: St. John’s Prep; junior; guard; averaged 9.0 points and 3.0 rebounds per game
‘A’
Lucy Kuhlman: Fontbonne Hall Academy, Bay Ridge; senior; guard; team co-captain; averaged 12.0 points; selected CHSAA ‘A’ All- League First Team; named recipient of CHSAA Sue Shepard Sportsmanship Award
Maryann Polanco: Fontbonne Hall; junior; center; team co-captain; averaged 14.0 points; selected CHSAA ‘A’ All-League First Team
Summer Duffy: Fontbonne Hall; senior; guard; team co-captain; averaged 10.0 points; selected CHSAA ‘A’ All-League Third Team
Julia Walsh: St. Edmund Prep H.S., Sheepshead Bay; sophomore; guard; averaged 8.2 points per game
Nicolette Ramaglia: St. Edmund Prep; senior; guard; averaged 6.4 points and 2.3 steals per game
Maria Manouselakis: St. Edmund Prep; sophomore; guard; averaged 5.5 points and 3.5 assists per game
‘B’
Brielle Gardner: St. Saviour H.S., Park Slope; junior; guard; team co-captain; averaged 18.0 points and 6.0 rebounds; named CHSAA ‘B’ Division MVP; 2024 and 2025 Tablet All- Star
Ellie Browne: St. Saviour; junior; guard; team co-captain; averaged 15.0 points and 5.0 assists; selected CHSAA ‘B’ All-League Second Team; 2025 Tablet All-Star
Zuleyka Leyva: St. Saviour; junior; guard; team co-captain; averaged 10.0 points, 6.0 rebounds, and 3.0 steals; selected CHSAA ‘B’ All-League Second Team
Summer Green: Cristo Rey Brooklyn H.S., Flatbush; senior; guard; team captain; selected CHSAA ‘B’ All-League First Team; named recipient of CHSAA Cynthia McGrath Sportsmanship Award; 2025 Tablet All-Star
Krystal Drew: Cristo Rey Brooklyn; senior; forward; selected CHSAA ‘B’ All-League Third Team
Madison Telesford: Cristo Rey Brooklyn; senior; forward; selected CHSAA ‘B’ All-League Third Team
